Decrease font size
Default font size
Increase font size
May 25, 2012
 

Unecessary Gallbladder Removal?

Dear Ask The Doctor: A doctor told me today that I needed my gallbladder removed and scheduled surgery. After doing some research I am very hesitant. I'm 35 years old and my symptoms (for two months now) are pain and cramping of my LEFT flank and occur after eating and I can no longer eat as much as I used to. I'm having odd bowel movements several times a day. Sometimes its diarrhea, other times its been orange and lately its been dark green. I also have pain in my left hip that feels like its being pulled apart. I understand that this may not have anything to do with my main symptoms, but its presence came with the flank pain. I've had an Ultrasound, CT scan, blood work, and given a urine sample. The blood and urine showed nothing wrong. The CT and Ultrasound showed a small teardrop size polyp in my gallbladder and no stones. Is this doctor cut happy or should I really be concerned?

Dear Jahn: Your symptoms do not suggest a problem with your gallbladder. Removing your gallbladder may not provide you with any relief. While your symptoms are non-specific, they are more suggestive of a problem with your large intestines. You may have a condition such as Inflammatory Bowel Disease or Irritable Bowel Syndrome. You should speak to your doctor about doing a colonoscopy. This test is used to visualize the large intestine and may be able to identify the cause of your symptoms. This should be done before considering removing the gallbaldder.

Last Updated ( Saturday, 01 January 2011 )
 

Related Articles

Stomach issues - alternating symptoms of loose stool and constipation

Finding Hair in Stool, Eating Another Persons Hair While Sleeping.

Stomach pain should I see doctor or go to ER

Sever pain abdomen and blood in stools

Digestive disorder - increased bloating and loose stools for several days

Pain upper abdomen after injury

Multiple irritated spots in colon?

Stomach Issues and lot of burping

Positive fecal occult blood test - declined a coloscopy

Foul smelling burps - Management

Difficulty in swallowing, which doctor should I see?

Pain in the right lower abdomen.

Digestive problem, what could be the cause?

What is the Cause of Light Colored Stools/

Heartburn and Indigestion Mostly during the Night

Swallowing a Golf Ball

Why does my Xray show distended bowel loops?

Food not passing through stomach

Mild Colitis diagnosis after discontinuing medication

Milk of Magnesia and Daily Consumption

Excessive bowel movements and IBS

Chronic dirrhea and hot sensation.

Gallbladder removal and weight gain

Swallowing Complications after surgery - help

Characterisitics of Gastroparesis

Problems with gases and bloating and getting worse

Black stool

Gastric pain

Abdominal pain and tenderness

Blood in the stool and lactose intolerance

Altered bowel habit with blood and mucus PR

Blood in the stools

If half the world carries Helicobacter Pylori, what's the point of treating it?

Upper and lower gastrointestinal bleeding

Bloody stools

Early Satiety

Bleeding from the back passage

Digestion issues

Colonoscopy

Abdominal bloating and extreme gas at night

Bowl Obstruction, rectal bleeding, stomach pain, five days no bowl movement

Liver and Gall bladder

Atypical shoulder pain

Symptoms following gallbladder removal surgery

Intermittent Bloating

Symptoms suggestive of oesophageal narrowing

Irregular bowels

What causes nausea

Bowel movement with red liquid

Small bowel obstruction

Cronic Pancreaitits

Peptic ulceration secondary to the use of Meloxicam

Overflow Diarrhoea Secondary to Chronic Constipation

Pyloric Valve Disease

Aorto-mesenteric clamp – a rare cause of abdominal pain and obstruction

Severe Abdominal Pain Requiring Further Investigation

Menstrual Cycles After a Colonoscopy

Prilosec OTC Question

Difficulty Swallowing due to Mechanical or Functional Causes

The use of a food diary to record symptoms

What Digestive Disorder Do I Have: Acid Reflux or GERD?

Gastritis secondary to Meloxicam use

Gallbladder Issues

Digestive Problems and Improving Constipation

Causes of Green Bowel Movements

Complex Gastointestinal History

Iron Overdose and no Symptoms

Loose stool and Antibiotic Use

Which is the best diagnostic tool to determine a bowel obstruction?

Gastrogavage

Undigested pills and food in Diabetic Mother

Bowel Obstruction After Taking Pain Killers

IBS and Bleeding from Bowel

Managing Acute Pancreatitis after the Hospital

Vomiting

About us | Follow us | Contact us | Advertising | Careers | Terms of Service | Site Map