Can a Bag of Water really cause failure to progress


Q: I have had 2 vaginal deliveries. The first was in a hospital with an OB and I arrived at 7cm dilated 0 station, and with a "bulging" bag of water. My Dr. performed AROM and my baby was posterior. It took 2 hours for me to dilate to 10 and have my baby. My second vaginal delivery I chose to have my baby at a birth center with a midwife. With this delivery, I again, showed up to the birth center at 7cm dilated 0 station, with a bulging bag of water. She on the other hand did NOT break my water. She said that AROM statistically has not been proven to speed up labor and that it would eventually break on its own. After several checks to confirm baby's position, I was told he was in a good position and we just need to "wait" for him to come down. He never did. I suffered for 7 hours of contractions with absolutely no change. Finally after I told them if they didn't break it, I was going to transfer to the hospital, she broke it and I was pushing within 20 min and had my baby 15 min after that. So my question is can a "tough bulging" bag of water have been the cause of a 7 hour transition and if so can you explain to me medically why that is?


A:   This question is currently in queue and will be answered shortly by one of our doctors. In the meantime you may browse our library of answered questions by clicking here.

Related Q&A

Q: Is it possible for me to be pregnant? Are these signs? Is it too early to tell? I had unprotected sex on 12/16/16, an...

Q: I had my period from 12- 18 and realised drops of blood from 18-25.had sex on 5-10 but he produced outside .i feel bl...

Q: Hello, I took the morning after pill (19th November) whilst I was at the end of my first period and within two weeks ...

Q: Hi I had unprotected sex on my ovulation day or at least around that time. But I still had my period thirteen days a...

Q: On the poor advice from someone at Planned Parenthood (who I think was a volunteer and not a professional), about a w...


Dr. James Obaji M.D.

  • 247 Reviews
  • Family Physician

Dr. Suneel Sharman M.D.

  • 190 Reviews
  • Family Physician

Dr. Pat Golden M.D.

  • 169 Reviews
  • Cardiologist

Dr. Kunaal Jindal M.D.

  • 112 Reviews
  • Plastic Surgeon