Hi Doctor, I've been just diagnosed with a D12 compression fracture,


Q: Hi Doctor,

I've been just diagnosed with a D12 compression fracture, had a car crash last night where my car was sandwitched between two cars. I'm a 30 year old male. The doctors say it might need surgery where he will bolt some screws on.

I've had a similar car crash back in 2010, where I was diagnosed a L2 compression fracture. I wore a brace for some months. Went on to doing some back strengthing exercises at the gym and was okay. Didn't opt for a surgery. Had it also checked this time and that bit has healed now.

I'm not very keen on the surgery, as I have heard from lot of people who have gone through it that it keeps coming back.

Please advise, need a second opinion.

Thank you


A:   Hi.
Thanks for your query.

Read and understood your history and the findings.
D 12 compression fracture due to car accident yesterday and L2 compression fracture in 2010.
Surgery or no Surgery in this situation depends upon many factors.
- Actual MRI and CT scan findings.
- Its correlation with the clinical findings.
- The problems you are facing.
- Age and sex of the patient.
- Any neurological deficits present or not at the moment or is expected in future as you already have 2 accidents with compression fractures of tow different vertebra in the lower back at different times.

For this I would advise you the best thing:
Always go for 2 opinions; one of the Orthopedic Surgeon who is operating spine and a Neurosurgeon too.
If both of them are suggesting for surgery, go for it. If both are differing go for 3 rd opinion and go by majority.
In the meantime have regular follow-up. Take proper care as advised and take proper medicines.

I hope this answer helps you in decision-making.

Related Q&A

Q: Hello Dr. My son 10 years had laparoscopic acuteappendicitis operation 2 weeks back on 9th oct and on 17thOct we had...

Q: Hi, I've just found a skin tag like grown on my Perineum I'm female.

Q: I have stomach problems frequent bowels movements, sometimes a cramping diarrhea with burning stomach mostly after ...

Q: I slept with somebody that has vaginal herpes and I used condom but my tongue touched her vagiana. She said she didn'...

Q: I am a 69 year old woman and have suffered from a lack of iron all my life. I do not take regular medicine but every...


Dr. James Obaji M.D.

  • 247 Reviews
  • Family Physician

Dr. Suneel Sharman M.D.

  • 190 Reviews
  • Family Physician

Dr. Pat Golden M.D.

  • 169 Reviews
  • Cardiologist

Dr. Kunaal Jindal M.D.

  • 112 Reviews
  • Plastic Surgeon