Not laryngospams, so... what?


Q: This is not a question about asthma, I am putting it in this category in hopes that someone with knowledge of the respiratory system sees it.

My dad's girlfriend (female, age 52) has a serious respiratory problem. She has been having spontaneous episodes for the past 3 years, during which her throat slams shut. We've seen multiple specialists who have all agreed this is not asthma, but have given us little else to work with.
One doctor suggested laryngospasms, but the next doctor discounted it completely due to the fact that these episodes last MUCH longer than 30-60 seconds. We've had to call the paramedics each time it has happened, and by the time they arrive she is cyanotic and barely clinging onto consciousness. (Obviously she is still getting a small quantity of oxygen, she's likened it to breathing through a coffee straw.)
There are no constant variables here causation wise, there is not one specific thing causing these episodes (at least not that we are able to identify, and believe me we have tried.) They have happened in all different places, times, during different activities, after different meals. The results of her allergy test came back strange, she showed a mild reaction to everything, but the doctor ruled this non-causative.
She has been on inhalers, anticonvulsants, and we have EpiPens to use when the attacks happen. Nothing has helped.
She now has a custom-built trach in place with hopes of providing her with adequate oxygen when this happens again. It's a way to cope, yes, but I need answers here. None of her doctors seem to be putting any effort into figuring out what is wrong. It's like everyone has thrown their hands up and said 'Oh well, I give up."

This isn't a scratch or a cold. This is a life-threatening problem. While it may not be of import to all the doctors with 100 more patients to worry about, it is very important to her and my father.
Here's to hoping someone out knows what's going on, or can at least point us in the right direction.

Symptoms:  Throat closing

Related Q&A

Q: Need prescription refill, i ran out of my proair inhaler and need a new one, the weather has made my chest extra tigh...

Q: My chest feels like someone is pushing right in the middle. It hurts and I'm finding it painful to breathe. This has ...

Q: I wake up not being able to breath and i have to kinda gasp for air and afterward i have a tightness in my chest plea...

Q: I have asthma since childhood and using medicines since long time. Until recently i have no issues with my asthma and...

Q: I have a chronic cough. Before I start the cough my back gets really itchy. Every time. And then I need an inhaler....


Dr. James Obaji M.D.

  • 247 Reviews
  • Family Physician

Dr. Suneel Sharman M.D.

  • 190 Reviews
  • Family Physician

Dr. Pat Golden M.D.

  • 169 Reviews
  • Cardiologist

Dr. Kunaal Jindal M.D.

  • 112 Reviews
  • Plastic Surgeon