176 Physicians Online


Size of lung lesion and risk of malignancy

Dear Ask The Doctor:
I've been experiencing chest tightness and shortness of breath for almost a month now. My doctor sent me to the ER, where they did blood work, EKG breathing treatment, chest x-ray, CT scan, and stress test. My lung specialist said my lungs are clear, and my breathing function test was good. The CT scan did show a small nodule (half a centimeter) on my left lung. I do have a history of lung cancer (I never smoked), and my upper right lobe was removed 7 years ago. Next, a cardiologist did a heart catheterization and said my heart and arteries were like an 18-yr-old's. My specific question: Is it possible for a half centimeter lung nodule to cause my symptoms? Thank you.


I think it is unlikely that a nodule half a centimetre in size would cause your symptoms of shortness of breath and chest tightness. It is reassuring to note that all the investigations you had completed were normal. Larger lung lesions are more likely to be cancerous than smaller lesions. In one study, the likelihood of malignancy was 0.2 percent for nodules smaller than 3 mm, 0.9 percent for nodules 4 to 7 mm, 18 percent for nodules 8 to 20 mm, and 50 percent for nodules larger than 20 mm. Therefore if your lesion is approximately 5 mm there is about a 1% chance of malignancy. Your family doctor could arrange follow-up screening with CT scan to monitor size of this lesion.

Sign In to join in the conversation.

You’re in good hands, meet ATD’s founding physicians.

Dr. Suneel Sharman

  • Board Certified GP
  • CMO ATD Health Network Inc.
  • Adjunct Professor at U Of T

Dr. Kunaal Jindal

  • Board Certified Plastic Surgeon
  • Director ATD Health Network Inc.
  • Fellowship Training Atlanta, GA

Related Answers:

My grandmother (Dob: 2/2/48) is going through the immigration process and pet of the requirements are to have a TB te...

I am having part of my lung removed because I have a tumor. I play sports an want to know when will I be able to come...

My mother was diagnosed with stage 4 non small lung cancer which has spread to the brain with 3 tumors, in December. ...

I recently went through an X-ray part of a regular health checkup and I found a small node on my lower left lung of a...

I have shortness of breath and when I take deep breathes my left side of lungs I have sharp pains and hurts when I br...

Hello, my name is David, I am from Romania, I've been an active smoker for about an year now(i am 17), and about 2 da...

Can a person survive with only one lung? A friend of mine needs a lung transplant and I want to help him, if I can.

In December 2013 they found a nodule on my left lung in between the upper and lower when I had a ct scan. It was 9mm....

Hi! I'm working on a HOSA competition for Biomedical Debate, and this year, the topic is: Are e-cigarettes more harmf...

I am having trouble breathing, i am a smoker and i am 24 years of age... im finding hard to get that last bit of brea...