181 Physicians Online


Unecessary Gallbladder Removal?

Dear Ask The Doctor:
A doctor told me today that I needed my gallbladder removed and scheduled surgery. After doing some research I am very hesitant. I'm 35 years old and my symptoms (for two months now) are pain and cramping of my LEFT flank and occur after eating and I can no longer eat as much as I used to. I'm having odd bowel movements several times a day. Sometimes its diarrhea, other times its been orange and lately its been dark green. I also have pain in my left hip that feels like its being pulled apart. I understand that this may not have anything to do with my main symptoms, but its presence came with the flank pain. I've had an Ultrasound, CT scan, blood work, and given a urine sample. The blood and urine showed nothing wrong. The CT and Ultrasound showed a small teardrop size polyp in my gallbladder and no stones. Is this doctor cut happy or should I really be concerned?


Your symptoms do not suggest a problem with your gallbladder. Removing your gallbladder may not provide you with any relief. While your symptoms are non-specific, they are more suggestive of a problem with your large intestines. You may have a condition such as Inflammatory Bowel Disease or Irritable Bowel Syndrome. You should speak to your doctor about doing a colonoscopy. This test is used to visualize the large intestine and may be able to identify the cause of your symptoms. This should be done before considering removing the gallbaldder.

Sign In to join in the conversation.

You’re in good hands, meet ATD’s founding physicians.

Dr. Suneel Sharman

  • Board Certified GP
  • CMO ATD Health Network Inc.
  • Adjunct Professor at U Of T

Dr. Kunaal Jindal

  • Board Certified Plastic Surgeon
  • Director ATD Health Network Inc.
  • Fellowship Training Atlanta, GA

Related Answers:

Got feces in my mouth a couple days ago and now have pain in my abdomen. Will this pass?

I have had a persistent pain in my right upper quadrant. It started 5 years ago, along with intense bloating whenever...

Can someone please help me I have had my symptoms just over 4 month now and I have had 2 different diagnosis in that ...

Hi. Underwent an endoscopy a couple of weeks ago and a prepyloric nodule was removed. According to the Dr. it was ben...

Hello, I've been having the following symptoms however embarrassed / perhaps worried to visit my doctor. 1) Lower ri...

I cannot digest food properly, my stool is watery, I often see undigested food, the smell is worse than usual, I some...

My 75-year-old mother is complaining of too frequent urination and constipation alternating with messy, unfirm stools...

Sometimes when I have a BM, I also start vomiting. This was occasional until the last 2wks it has happened 4 times.

Hi, When I apply pressure below my bellow button, in line with my pelvic bones, it hurts - but only when pressure ...

I develop sudden intolerances to random, unrelated foods and the amount of food I cannot eat is piling up. What could...